The Art of the Investigative Interview: Human judgement still matters in the age of AI
"Please don't put me in front of an avatar or a bot - it's impersonal, inhuman and doesn't understand how I feel."
A witness interviewed during a trial of AI led interviewing
These are the exact words from a witness who was interviewed as part of an investigation, and as part of a trial using AI to conduct the interview.
Corporate investigations increasingly sit at the centre of organisational life. They help businesses respond to misconduct, protect people, understand risk, satisfy regulators, and make decisions that are fair, defensible and evidence-based. The Association of Corporate Investigators (ACi) has a mission to champion professional excellence in corporate investigations, connecting and informing investigators across more than 70 countries, and supporting work carried out with rigour, integrity and independence. In that context, the investigative interview remains one of the most important—and most human—skills in the investigator’s craft. The mission could easily fail if we don’t preserve some of the fundamental assets belonging to the investigator, interviewing included.
The ACi Corporate Investigator’s Handbook (published in association with GIR) puts the point plainly: interviews form an integral part of the investigative process. Documents, emails, chat records, access logs and transaction data may establish the underlying facts. But facts rarely speak in full sentences. They do not always explain why something happened, what a person understood at the time, whether a decision was deliberate or mistaken, or how competing accounts should be weighed. That is where interviews matter. They bring context, sequencing, rationale and credibility into view.
At its best, an investigative interview is not adversarial, an interrogation, a script-reading exercise or a box-ticking compliance event. It is a structured professional conversation. It has a purpose, but it also requires listening. It has a plan, but it must adapt. It seeks evidence, but it must respect the dignity of the person being interviewed. Investigators know the value of listening to understand and not responding. Comprehending explanations is critical. Comprehension is human understanding not merely AI interpretation. Whether the individual is a reporter, concern raiser, witness, affected party, subject of investigation or third party, the handbook guidance stresses the need for equal regard. That principle is easy to write down and difficult to practise well. It requires discipline, empathy, patience and judgement.
Preparation is the first mark of a good interview
Preparation is the first mark of a good interview. The old saying that poor planning leads to poor performance is particularly apt in investigations. Before an interview begins, the investigator should understand the investigation plan, the issues in scope, the available evidence, the legal and cultural context, and the purpose of speaking to that particular person at that particular time. In cross-border matters, local law and practice may shape what can be asked, how the interview should be recorded, who may attend, and what warnings or protections are required.
A human-led process recognises these dimensions before the first question is asked.
Where AI helps - and where it does not
This is also where the debate about artificial intelligence needs balance. AI can be extremely useful in corporate investigations. It can help identify patterns in large data sets, summarise chronologies, cluster documents, translate material, surface inconsistencies and support preparation. Used responsibly, it can free investigators to spend more time on judgement-intensive work. But the interview itself should not be handed over to AI, because an interview is not simply a data extraction event. It is a live human encounter in which trust, fairness, proportionality and interpretation all matter.
Nevertheless, there is a place for AI within the training environment.
An AI system can generate questions, although it cannot carry accountability in the way an investigator must. It cannot truly understand organisational nuance, personal vulnerability, hesitation, silence, cultural context, workplace power dynamics or the significance of a witness correcting themselves after reflection. It may detect linguistic patterns, but it does not know whether a person is confused, intimidated, guarded, traumatised, overconfident or simply trying to be precise. A skilled investigator notices not just what is said, but what needs to be clarified; not just what is missing, but whether the absence is meaningful. Where AI can help, is to assist with training scenarios, and the ACi are at the forefront of this development tool.
AI may assist in mapping contradictions across material. It should not be the arbiter of credibility
The credibility assessment that often follows an interview is also profoundly human. It must be careful, evidence-led and free from lazy assumptions. Credibility is not about whether someone appears confident, polished or emotional. It is about the consistency of their account with the evidence, the plausibility of explanations, the opportunity they had to observe events, the limits of their recollection, and how their evidence sits within the wider investigation. AI may assist in mapping contradictions across material. It should not be the arbiter of credibility.
There is a further issue: confidence in the process. Employees, regulators, boards and courts expect investigations to be fair, independent and robust. A person asked to participate in an interview must believe that they are being heard by someone capable of understanding their account and treating it appropriately. If organisations outsource that human engagement to a machine, they risk weakening trust in the process. They may also miss the very insights the interview is designed to obtain: context, intent, concerns, pressures, culture and lessons for the organisation.
Investigator-led, technology enabled
The better approach is not “AI or investigator”; it is investigator-led, technology-enabled practice. Investigators can use AI to prepare better, test hypotheses, organise evidence and reduce administrative burden. But interview strategy, questioning, rapport, challenge, safeguarding, fairness and final evaluation should remain with trained professionals. The ACi’s emphasis on professional excellence, shared standards, education and peer collaboration is especially relevant here. The future of investigations should not be less human. It should be more disciplined about where human judgement is indispensable.
The future of investigations should nit be less humans. It should be more disciplined about where human judgment is indespensible.
The practical lesson for AI leaders
For leaders, the lesson is practical. Invest in interview training. Give investigators time to prepare. Ensure interview plans are aligned with the investigation strategy. Respect local legal requirements. Record interviews accurately. Treat all interviewees with equal regard. Use technology thoughtfully, but do not confuse speed with quality or automation with fairness. The strongest investigations are not those that simply collect the most data. They are those that ask the right questions, listen properly to the answers, and integrate human accounts with documentary evidence in a careful and defensible way.
The investigative interview is an art because it combines structure with judgement, evidence with empathy, and challenge with fairness. It is also a professional discipline, grounded in preparation, legal awareness and ethical practice. AI will change how investigators work, and in many respects it already has. But the central conversation—the moment when one person seeks to understand another person’s account of events—should remain human-led. In corporate investigations, that is not nostalgia. It is a safeguard for accuracy, fairness and trust.
Are Investigations Always Necessary?
Foreword
Investigations are a critical component of effective governance, but they are also a serious intervention with significant organisational and human consequences. This paper addresses a growing challenge faced by many organisations: the tendency for concerns to default into full formal investigations, regardless of risk, materiality, or proportionality.
As reporting volumes increase and regulatory expectations evolve, organisations are under sustained pressure to demonstrate diligence. In response, investigative systems have increasingly favoured escalation over judgment.
While well-intentioned, this approach has led to investigative congestion, misallocation of governance resources, delayed outcomes in serious matters, and avoidable harm to individuals whose integrity may be compromised by unnecessary process. This paper makes a clear case that reducing unnecessary investigations is not a reduction in governance or compliance. On the contrary, strong governance is defined by the quality, consistency, and defensibility of decision-making—not by the volume of investigative activity. Regulators and stakeholders increasingly expect organizations to demonstrate that concerns have been assessed thoughtfully, documented appropriately, and addressed in a manner proportionate to risk. A well-reasoned decision not to investigate can be as robust and defensible as a decision to proceed.
The paper also recognises that investigations, regardless of outcome, carry inherent reputational and personal consequences. A governance system that escalates matters without sufficient justification risks substituting procedural defensibility for substantive fairness. Protecting the integrity and dignity of individuals is therefore not in tension with compliance obligations; it is a fundamental element of ethical, sustainable governance.
Accordingly, this paper advocates for a disciplined, risk-based approach to investigation triage. It positions triage as a governance control—not an administrative step—and emphasises the importance of early, well-documented decisions to close, resolve, or redirect matters where a full investigation is not warranted. By doing so, organisations can preserve investigative capacity for genuinely serious issues, strengthen regulatory outcomes, and maintain trust in their reporting and governance frameworks. Ultimately, mature governance is demonstrated not by investigating everything, but by knowing when not to.
This ACi guide forms part of a wider collection of reference materials, all designed to assist those whoare directing, managing, leading or conducting corporate investigations.
Why is it important not to investigate unnecessarily
Unnecessary investigations impose material organisational, legal, and human costs without delivering proportional governance benefits. Corporate investigation triage has increasingly become a mechanism for prioritisation rather than reduction, resulting in “over-triage” where minor issues are escalated into full investigations by default. The ACi has noted in its research activities that this process is now being reviewed by many organisations who have undergone ISO37008 reviews (and are considering the application of ISO37012) as structural drivers have been seen to reinforce this problem.
Rising report volumes—driven by improved reporting cultures and expanded digital footprints—overwhelm triage functions and reduce the practical ability to confidently dismiss low-risk matters. In this environment, senior leaders and Heads of Investigation frequently err on the side of escalation, not because the issue warrants it, but because doing nothing feels riskier than doing too much. This is changing as the dynamic is compounded by risk aversion and regulatory pressure.
A pervasive “fear of missing something,” has previously led organisations to treat moderate or low-level issues as “high risk” simply to demonstrate diligence, and observation suggests this as misplaced, particularly with Regulators. Over time, this approach dilutes investigative focus, consumes scarce resources, and slows response times for genuinely serious matters. In effect, unnecessary investigations weaken—not strengthen—the overall effectiveness of governance by flooding the system with low-value activity.
Why reducing investigations is NOT a reduction in Governance or Compliance
A common misconception is that fewer investigations equate to weaker governance. The document directly challenges this assumption by clarifying that triage is intended as a filtering system, not an automatic gateway to full investigation.
Strong governance is not measured by the volume of investigations conducted, but by the quality, proportionality, and defensibility of decision-making. Regulators increasingly expect organisations to demonstrate that complaints were considered, assessed and documented- not that every allegation resulted in a full investigation. A well-reasoned decision to close or resolve a matter early—supported by documented triage criteria—can be as defensible as launching an investigation, and often more so.
Moreover, policy and legal constraints that mandate full investigations for every formal complaint can inadvertently undermine compliance objectives. When investigative teams are stretched thin by excessive and often unnecessary caseloads, complex and high-risk investigations receive less attention, increasing the likelihood of errors, delays, or superficial outcomes.
Reducing unnecessary investigations therefore reallocates governance capacity toward the matters that truly require it, enhancing compliance rather than eroding it.
In this sense, a reduction in investigations—when driven by disciplined triage and clear thresholds—is evidence of governance maturity, not governance retreat.
Why it is critical not to unnecessarily damage the integrity of individuals
Unnecessary investigations carry profound human consequences that are often underestimated. Even when no wrongdoing is found, the mere existence of an investigation can damage an individual’s reputation, credibility, and psychological wellbeing. Once an investigation enters the pipeline, it is difficult to stop, largely due to fear of litigation and internal policy rigidity.
This creates a structural injustice: individuals may be subjected to prolonged scrutiny not because the evidence warrants it, but because (often over complex and over-documented) organisational systems and processes are biased toward escalation.
The subjectivity and bias inherent in triage decisions—particularly confirmation bias—can further entrench this harm, as investigators may unconsciously seek information that justifies continuing the investigation rather than reassessing its necessity.
From a governance perspective, this is not a neutral outcome. Investigative overreach can erode trust in reporting systems, discourage cooperation, and foster a culture of fear rather than accountability.
Protecting the integrity of individuals is therefore not in tension with compliance; it is a core component of ethical governance. A system that routinely investigates without sufficient justification risks substituting procedural defensibility for substantive fairness.
Protecting the integrity of individuals is therefore not in tension with compliance; it is a core component of ethical governance. A system that routinely investigates without sufficient justification risks substituting procedural defensibility for substantive fairness.
Triage and Assessment - Getting it right
Modern investigation triage often fails to reduce investigative volume, not because reduction is inappropriate, but because organisational incentives favour escalation over common sense and good judgment. Unnecessary investigations weaken governance effectiveness, misallocate resources, and inflict avoidable harm on individuals.
Reducing investigations—when done through robust, well-documented triage—is not a reduction in governance or compliance. It is an affirmation that governance is about proportionate response, disciplined risk assessment, and respect for individual integrity.
The ACi have found that many mature organisations demonstrate compliance not by investigating everything, but by knowing when not to. When it comes to the applicability within internal policies, the ACi are clear that any organisational approach to investigations must be proportionate, risk-based, and fair.
To this end, not every allegation warrants a full formal investigation. The purpose of triage is not merely to sequence investigative activity, but to determine—on a reasoned and documented basis—whether an investigation is necessary at all. A disciplined approach to triage and early resolution strengthens governance, preserves organisational resources, and protects individual integrity, while ensuring that serious matters receive appropriate attention.
The importance of avoiding unnecessary investigations
Unnecessary investigations impose significant costs without delivering corresponding governance value. These costs include diversion of management attention, depletion of investigative capacity, increased legal and forensic expenditure, and individual / organisational disruption. As reporting volumes continue to rise, indiscriminate escalation of matters into full investigations risks overwhelming investigative functions and reducing overall effectiveness.
A system that ultimately “defaults to investigation” in the absence of clear risk thresholds encourages defensive decision-making rather than sound judgment. Over time, this approach leads to investigative congestion, delayed outcomes, and reduced responsiveness to genuinely serious issues. From a board perspective, this represents a misallocation of governance capacity and an erosion of risk prioritisation. Effective governance requires the ability to distinguish between matters that require formal investigation and those that can be resolved through alternative, proportionate mechanisms. Avoiding unnecessary investigations is therefore not an abdication of oversight, but an essential component of responsible risk management.
The volume of investigations conducted is not a reliable indicator of governance strength. Governance quality is measured by the soundness, consistency, and defensibility of decision-making, not by activity levels alone. Regulators and enforcement authorities increasingly focus on whether organisations can demonstrate that concerns were appropriately assessed, documented, and addressed in a manner proportionate to risk. A well-reasoned decision not to investigate—supported by clear triage criteria and documented analysis—can be as defensible as a decision to investigate, and in many cases more so.
Excessive investigation activity can, in fact, undermine compliance objectives. When investigative resources are spread too thinly across low-risk or marginal matters, high-risk cases may receive insufficient attention, increasing the likelihood of delay, error, or superficial outcomes. Reducing unnecessary investigations allows organisations to concentrate expertise and scrutiny where it is most needed, strengthening regulatory outcomes and organisational resilience.
From a governance standpoint, a reduction in investigations driven by disciplined triage reflects maturity, confidence, and control—not reduced vigilance.
Summary
The volume of investigations conducted is not a reliable indicator of governance strength. Governance quality is measured by the soundness, consistency, and defensibility of decision-making, not by activity levels alone. Regulators and enforcement authorities increasingly focus on whether organisations can demonstrate that concerns were appropriately assessed, documented, and addressed in a manner proportionate to risk. A well-reasoned decision not to investigate—supported by clear triage criteria and documented analysis—can be as defensible as a decision to investigate, and in many cases more so.
Excessive investigation activity can, in fact, undermine compliance objectives. When investigative resources are spread too thinly across low-risk or marginal matters, high-risk cases may receive insufficient attention, increasing the likelihood of delay, error, or superficial outcomes. Reducing unnecessary investigations allows organisations to concentrate expertise and scrutiny where it is most needed, strengthening regulatory outcomes and organisational resilience. From a governance standpoint, a reduction in investigations driven by disciplined triage reflects maturity, confidence, and control—not reduced vigilance.
Investigations carry inherent reputational and personal consequences, regardless of outcome. Even where allegations are unfounded, the initiation of a formal investigation can cause lasting harm to an individual’s professional standing, wellbeing, and trust in the organisation.
A system that routinely escalates matters without sufficient justification creates a structural risk of unfairness. Once an investigation is initiated, organisational inertia, legal caution, and policy rigidity often make it difficult to stop, even where evidence does not support continuation. This can result in prolonged scrutiny that is disproportionate to the underlying issue.
From an ethical governance perspective, protecting individual integrity is not in tension with compliance obligations. On the contrary, fairness, proportionality, and respect for individuals are foundational to credible governance frameworks. Over-investigation risks replacing substantive justice with procedural defensibility, thereby undermining trust in both reporting mechanisms and investigative outcomes. Boards have a responsibility to ensure that governance systems do not cause avoidable harm through unnecessary process.
Conclusion
Organisations should recognise that:
Investigations are a serious intervention, not a default response.
Effective triage is a governance control - not an administrative step.
Reducing unnecessary investigations strengthens compliance by reallocating attention to material risk.
Protecting individual integrity is an essential component of ethical and sustainable governance.
The ACi have observed many organisations making significant strides into the reduction of investigated concerns as a result of their bold decision making frameworks and considering investigations to be a last resort, rather focussing on other informal and formal processes.
Accordingly, an organisation should commit to a triage framework that enables early, well-documented decisions to close, resolve, or redirect matters where a full investigation is not warranted, while ensuring that serious allegations are addressed promptly, thoroughly, and independently.
Using Hong Kong's Anti-Money Laundering Laws to Combat the Illegal Wildlife Trade
How a decade-log conversation campaign turned financial-crime controls into a tool for protecting endangered species -- and what corporate investigators can learn from it
How the Hong Kong ivory trade was banned
Achieving the ban involved deploying a wide range of campaigning tools to shine a light on systemic regulatory failings within the Hong Kong government's wildlife department — the Agricultural, Fisheries and Conservation Department (AFCD). WildAid's goal was to expose how Hong Kong's legal ivory trade was masking a parallel illegal trade in poached ivory, and how traders were abusing a failed licensing system. Somehow, the city's existing ivory stockpile, which was spread across around seventy licensed traders, never seemed to go down. WildAid enquiries suggested Hong Kong's legal stocks of raw ivory were being used as a cynical mechanism to launder freshly poached ivory onto the market, and legal enforcement of the permitting system was lax or non-existent. For WildAid's campaign to succeed they had to prove it.
Undercover footage: Subtitled admission from licensed traders.
Photo credit: WildAid
Alarmingly, during the mid-2010s, Hong Kong customs officers were making record breaking seizures of raw elephant tusks with increasing regularity. Every couple of months, they would seize another shipment of tonnes of fresh ivory from illegally killed African elephants from countries where elephant populations were being decimated, such as Kenya, Tanzania, Ivory Coast and Angola. Organised crime groups were smuggling vast quantities Of illegally poached ivory into Hong Kong through its Kwai Chung port, or by air into the city's busy international airport.
Photo credit: Alex Hofford
At one Hong Kong customs briefing, a seized elephant ivory tusk was so fresh that dried elephant blood could be seen and smelt encrusted around the end Of the tusk where it had been brutally severed from the poor creature's skull. This freshly poached ivory was quickly being carved into jewellery, bangles, necklaces, trinkets, or bogus antiques to be sold to tour groups of tourists from mainland China bussed into shops and luxury stores across Hong Kong. Clearly this posed legal and reputational risks for the city.
Photo credit: Alex Hofford
Follow the money
WildAid's public-facing media and social media campaign relied heavily on juxtaposing images Of seized raw ivory in Hong Kong with graphic images of slaughtered elephants in the beautiful expanses of Africa. However, one weapon in WildAid's arsenal which was kept firmly out of the public gaze was the leveraging of Hong Kong's anti-money laundering (AML) laws.
"The old adage follow the money applies to solving wildlife crime. Freezing of assets derived from illegal wildlife trade, and money laundering charges are important tools in stopping the extinction of endangered species. Where possible enforcement agencies should use organised crime laws with stiffer penalties and longer sentences to prosecute illegal wildlife trade."
Peter Knights, OBE — Chief Executive, Wild Africa
Going back a decade, financial investigations were rarely used in relation to illegal wildlife trade. The Royal United Services Institute (RUS') was the first organisation to systematically highlight this gap, through a JK-government-funded report published in 2017 which highlighted the significant potential of financial tools to disrupt those facilitating the trade at a high level.
"Efforts to follow the money had long been neglected in this thematic area. They hold significant potential to allow investigators to go beyond low-level poachers and identify those directing illegal wildlife trade at a higher level. Significant investment has been made in the interim to build capacity to follow the financial footprints at a global level. This work is challenging, however, and requires concerted commitment from public and private-sector alike — which has not been forthcoming in all cases."
Cathy Haenlein, Director of Organised Crime and policing Studies, Rusi
In the WildAid case, to combat the illicit financial flows generated by several known or suspected Hong Kong based illegal wildlife traffickers, who operated with impunity across immense shadowy networks spanning several African countries, as well as China, Vietnam, and Laos, WildAid simply followed the money. Through a trusted intermediary, WildAid supplied multiple lists of known or suspected illegal wildlife traders to third parties who would then make them available to banks and Other regulated financial institutions. This was so they could screen and hopefully match them with existing lists from the global AML community. For example, these might have included lists of sanctioned individuals or entities, terrorist financing lists, specially designated individual lists, or other lists of high-risk individuals or entities. These lists might have been held by the banks themselves, or by the Financial Action Task Force (FAT F), the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), the European Union, or the United States Office Of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC). A suspicion has long existed in wildlife conservation circles that there is link between the illegal wildlife trade and terrorist financing.
WildAid's campaign began small. In early 2015, they decided that to properly illustrate the scale Of Hong Kong's out-of control ivory trade, they simply had to map it. Their market survey began in Hong Kong's antique district centred around Hollywood Road. It grew rapidly from there until they had recorded information on every retail outlet selling ivory in the city. In English and Chinese, WildAid consultants recorded company names, individual names, phone numbers, addresses, email addresses, license numbers if they were available, and often took photographic evidence too. From Chinese state owned high end jewellery stores in gleaming towers Of glass and steel, from luxury shopping malls to humble hole in the wall operators in Kowloon, WildAid's market survey spreadsheet eventually grew to over a hundred rows.
As the hot summer Of 2015 wore on, WildAid's simple market survey turned into a full-blown investigation. Securing video evidence to support their case was key For the larger, more egregious, ivory traders, WildAid used a range of subterfuge tactics to gain access to premises to obtain intelligence and video footage Of ivory stocks which they then fed to the media to support their campaign. Undercover volunteers met with raw elephant ivory tusk traders that they knew were illegally supplying carvers in China, which itself was an illegal cross border multi jurisdictional activity. Undercover footage included ivory traders boasting that they could place calls to the agents of poachers in Kenya and Tanzania to kill elephants on order. Often these individuals had links to organised crime. Eventually, through a CNN exclusive. WildAid blew the lid Off the Hong Kong ivory trade.
In 2016, Liberty Asia, a charity focussed on reducing human trafficking approached WildAid with an Offer to collaborate Liberty Asia believe that the best way to tackle human trafficking — and illegal wildlife trafficking is to follow the money They believed that a highly effective way to save elephants would be to hit the smugglers in their pockets. WildAid then began to pass its raw data to Liberty Asia in the form of spreadsheets from its market survey of illegal wildlife traders it suspected of selling freshly poached ivory and money laundering. Acting as a safe conduit, Liberty Asia would take WildAid's information, anonymise it, then pass it to LSEG World-Check, LexisNexis WorldCompliance and Dow Jones. These large third party companies would clean up the data and present it in their own format to a wide range of banks and financial institutions through their global subscription-based databases. For obvious reasons, this was conducted out of the public eye Of course, due to the black box and one-way direction nature of the information flow, it is impossible to know if any of WildAid's information generated a match for any trader on, for example, an Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) list of Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked persons (SDN) sanctions list, a terrorist financing list, or any other kind of list, but it is suspected to have done so, which made the efforts all worthwhile.
WildAid found out later that much Of the smuggling that fuelled Hong Kong's illegal wildlife trade was facilitated by the South African branch of Taiwan's Bamboo Union Gang as well as Hong Kong's infamous 14K triad gang.
Hong Kong honorary consuls to African countries
WildAid also provided Liberty Asia information on Politically Exposed Persons, or PEPS, in Hong Kong. These included honorary consuls to African countries WildAid suspected of having links to the illegal wildlife trade. Wealthy Hong Kong businessmen still operate as consular representatives Of African countries which were homes to large herds of elephants subject to spiking poaching rates. In 2015, a few of these honorary consuls were found to be operating jewellery shops selling carved poached ivory items in Kowloon, one of the main tourist hubs of Hong Kong. Were these PEPS using their diplomatic bags to smuggle ivory tusks buried within large consignments of gemstones mined in East Africa, but carved and polished in Hong Kong factories? It will never be known for sure, but it is strongly suspected to be the case.
Photo credit: Facebook
"The illicit trade in natural resources — from ivory and timber to critical minerals — flows from Africa to Asia through complex networks that often rely on front companies to conceal the true beneficiaries. Financial investigations remain the most effective means of exposing beneficial ownership and unravelling the fraudulent and corrupt practices that sustain this trade. Without systematic financial scrutiny, traffickers operate with near impunity, perpetuating environmental destruction and undermining the rule of law."
Giovnni Broussard, Africa Coordinator, UNODC Environment Team
One of the Hong Kong honorary consuls WildAid had suspicions about still runs a complex web of over 80 companies, including several offshore companies based in the British Virgin Islands. His companies' main purpose Of business is the export Of raw materials to China from areas Of a large country in central Africa notorious for elephant poaching. These commodities included sand, gravel, gypsum, iron ore, zinc, copper, coal, gold and timber. This honorary consul relied on shipping vast quantities of these commodities within giant bulk carrier vessels with cavernous hulls where anything of size can be easily hidden from prying customs officials. Think, for example, of a crate of ivory tusks or weapons buried beneath thousands of tonnes of sand dredged from a river estuary. Again, it is hard to prove but, over the course of WildAid's investigation, initial concerns hardened into strong suspicions, especially when coupled with evidence of past criminality and insider trading.
Photo credit: Mongabay
To raise the profile of WildAid's public-facing campaign to ban the Hong Kong ivory trade, their survey data provided the basis for their 2017 report into regulatory failings of the city's legal ivory trade which was entitled. However, many of WildAid's suspicions had to be left out of the report as they could only publish confirmed facts rather than speculation. But in the world Of AML suspicions are fair game.
At around this time, Prince William's Royal Foundation led-programme, United for Wildlife, established its Transport Taskforce and later its Financial Taskforce to tackle illegal wildlife trafficking, one of the most significant and harmful forms of serious and organised crime and which has the greatest impact beyond purely financial terms. To combat it, Prince William brought together representatives from the corporate sector alongside wildlife conservation charities working on anti poaching in Africa and demand reduction in Asia to protect endangered wildlife. Corporate members Of the United for Wildlife Transport Taskforce included airlines, shipping lines, logistics companies, and port operators, while banks and regulated financial institutions made up its Financial Taskforce. It was at one of the first meetings of United for Wildlife's Financial Taskforce in Hong Kong, the charity groups and members of the corporate sector were first introduced to the now familiar nomenclature of the AML world such as 'red flags', 'suspicious transaction reports' and 'enhanced due diligence'.
"The majority of wildlife trafficking, specifically the movement of the illicit goods, was taking place via commercial infrastructures. The transport and financial sectors were unwittingly being targeted by criminal networks to move both physical products and finances around the world. By bringing together groups of private and civil sectors to share trends and analysis, it allowed these corporates to collectively develop red flag indicators and typologies in their sectors, establishing industry guidelines and new regulations, while also bringing their own resources in to combat IVVT globally."
Robert Campbell, 04 OSCO Programme Director, United for Wildlife
OSCO
A couple of years later, having exposed the dire regulatory failings of Hong Kong's endangered species sales and possession control licensing regime, and to highlight the growing importance of combating illicit financial flows in the global illegal wildlife trade, another piece Of the jigsaw began to fall into place. This came in the form of a further WildAid initiative, an amendment to Hong Kong's wildlife laws so that they could be added to a schedule of 'predicate offences' under the city's Organised and Serious Crimes Ordinance (OSCO).
Because of its colonial past, Hong Kong still practices English Common Law and the OSCO has features similar to the United Kingdom's Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 (POCA). Both laws function as omnibus legislation designed to combat organised crime by targeting its financial incentives. In 2017, WildAid drafted a letter on behalf Of NGOs to the then Hong Kong leader Leung Chun-ying calling on the territory's government to drastically increase penalties for wildlife crime and add wildlife related offences to the schedule of the OSCO. In 2018, the letter was repurposed, adding a lot more legal details with the help of Professor Amanda Whitfort, a legal expert in animal law at the University Of Hong Kong. It was then passed to Elizabeth Quat, a supportive Hong Kong lawmaker, for her to send to Hong Kong's Secretary for Security for his consideration. These letters formed the nascent kernel of a WildAid campaign that eventually brought in other wildlife charities and which finally resulted in Ms Quat presenting her Organised and Serious Crimes (Amendment) Bill 2021 to Hong Kong's law making body, the Legislative Council. Eventually, the following offences from Hong Kong's Protection of Endangered Species of Animals and Plants Ordinance (Cap. 586) were added to Schedule One of Hong Kong's OSCO (Cap. 455) on 18 August 2021:
Cap. 455 Schedule1 – Item 20
Protection of Endangered Species of Animals and Plants Ordinance (Cap. 586)
Section
Offence
Section 5
Illegal import of specimen of an Appendix I species
Section 6
Illegal introduction from the sea of a specimen of an Appendix I Species
Section 7
Illegal export of a specimen of an Appendix I species
Section 8
Illegal re-export of a specimen of an Appendix I species
Section 9
Illegal possession or control of a specimen of an Appendix I species
Section 11
Illegal import of a specimen of an Appendix II or III species
Section 12
Illegal introduction from the sea of a specimen of an Appendix II or III species
Section 13
Illegal export of a specimen of an Appendix II or III species
Section 14
Illegal re-export of a specimen of n Appendix II or III species
Section 15
Illegal possession or control of a specimen of an Appendix II species
Added 23 Of 2021 s. 3. Short descriptions Of Offences are for ease Of reference only. Source: — Cap. 455
The Bill contained the following interesting background:
"Wildlife trafficking and illegal trade are highly lucrative and attractive to criminal organizations and syndicates. Despite the May 2018 amendment to the Protection Of Endangered Species Of Animals and Plants Ordinance (PESAPO) (Cap. 586) to increase the maximum penalties Of offences under it, wildlife seizures in Hong Kong continued to reach new peaks in 2019 and 2020. In 2019, record seizure Of 8.3 metric tonnes (MT) Of pangolin along with 2.1 MT Of ivory was made in a container from Nigeria. In the same year, the largest seizure of 82.5kg of rhino horn was made from cargo transhipment in the Hong Kong International Airport April and May 2020 saw two almost identical seizures Of 13 MT Of shark fins. Even though the maximum penalties Of offences under Cap 586 were increased by 900%, the fact remains that neither the penalties under the Ordinance nor the powers it confers to investigators and enforcers are sufficient to effectively deter criminal organizations. "
Sometimes wildlife conservation victories can take years. In a Iow-key press release issued on 9 July 2025, the Hong Kong authorities announced that two men had been prosecuted with enhanced sentencing under OSCO for illegal possession of an endangered turtle species. For wildlife conservation, this was a landmark moment. Now, under the OSCO, the Hong Kong authorities were finally going after wildlife smugglers with increased powers. They could impose longer jail sentences and higher fines on criminals, as well as seize or confiscate their assets. The law would now also force financial institutions to report wildlife related money laundering offences and suspicious transactions to the Hong Kong's Joint Financial Investigation Unit. Placing Hong Kong's wildlife laws under the OSCO also allowed authorities to use specialised tools for financial investigations of suspected illegal wildlife traffickers, such as restraint orders to freeze assets and production orders to obtain bank records. All Of this created a new deterrent effect.
"While the amendment to OSCO should have been a gamechanger for Hong Kong, it is disappointing that to date there has been very limited use by law enforcement of their new powers."Amanda Whitfort, Associate Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Hong Kong
"Hong Kong now has powerful legislation, but it's impotent without equally powerful, transnational investigations. The authorities are clearly able to intercept wildlife shipments but should make more effective use of pro-active techniques like controlled deliveries to identify, arrest and prosecute members of organised criminal networks who still seem largely undeterred from trafficking wildlife through Hong Kong."
Justin Gosling, Law Enforcement Specialist, Environmental Investigation Agency
As its political and legal climate darkens. time will tell if Hong Kong remains a reliable ally in the global battle to save endangered species from extinction.
On Ethics: Patrick Wellens
From finance and audit to compliance
AT: By my calculation, you have been a part of the ethics and compliance community for over 20 years now, after having worked many years in finance and audit. What brought you into it?
PW: While working as country chief financial officer, regional finance manager, and within the internal audit department of large corporations, my primary focus was on evaluating the
effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting, protecting company assets against fraud, and ensuring that
operational risks are well managed. As I speak numerous languages and have the necessary certifications, I was often asked by boards to investigate sensitive compliance incidents around the world. Understanding the root causes and behaviors of fraudsters opened the world of compliance to me.
How Compliance has evolved
AT: Thinking back to that time, how would you describe ethics and compliance programs in the early 2000s?
PW: Compared to now, in the early 2000s, ethics and compliance programs were primitive. The primary focus of compliance programs in the 2000s was to avoid fines, prosecutions, and reputational damage. The focus of the compliance program was on financial reporting, anti-corruption, antitrust, and insider trading, and compliance was executed by small departments led by legal teams. Compliance was viewed as a defensive, legal, and procedural function.
AT: What are some of the positive changes you have seen?
PW: Since the early 2000s, many guidance documents by regulators and independent organizations like the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) have been created so companies know what is expected from them regarding an effective compliance management system. The number of laws that companies need to comply with (e.g., supply-chain transparency laws, human rights, AI, data privacy, cybersecurity) has expanded exponentially. Combined with increased expectations from investors and stakeholders looking for companies that demonstrate strong ethical governance, responsible social practices, and environmental stewardship, integrity is now a fundamental driver of long-term value and resilience. Furthermore, academic research has shown the direct correlation between a strong ethical culture and reduced misconduct, improved financial performance, and enhanced reputation. In many organizations, the chief ethics and compliance officer or chief integrity officer positions have been created and report to the board. The size of compliance departments versus the early 2000s has expanded substantially — also driven by the increased scope of compliance. Data privacy, cybersecurity, ethical use of AI, human rights, environmental, social, and governance (ESG) reporting, etc., have been added to the traditional anti corruption and antitrust focus. Today’s compliance departments have more technological solutions and data points at their disposal to measure ethical culture than in the early days (e.g., speak-up channels, data analytics, culture surveys, AI for monitoring, integrated governance, risk and compliance platforms).
AT: One of the more notable changes I have noticed since I joining this community back in 2000 is a movement away from a strictly legalistic approach toward one that is more human-centric. Do you have the same sense? Do you think we are moving in the right direction, or should we be thinking differently?
PW: Yes, compliance has evolved from being primarily rule-based and punitive — focused on adhering to laws and avoiding penalties in the 2000s — toward being values-based and behavioral now. We see companies experimenting with bringing behavioral scientists into compliance teams, compliance departments focusing on intrinsic motivation (“doing the right thing”) rather than extrinsic fear (“avoiding punishment”), and controls being replaced by trust. This is indeed a step in the right direction; however, values and trust only will not work. They need to be embedded in broader ethics and compliance frameworks. In the future, I expect compliance departments to use much more behavioral data and data analytics to provide compliance guidance.
Who Compliance reports to
AT: One other notable change in compliance is that it has — overall but not everywhere — moved up in the organization. It used to be that virtually every compliance or ethics officer reported to general counsel. Now, that’s less and less the case. But there is still some resistance. Why do you think that is?
PW: First, despite guidance from ISO 37301 (Compliance Management Systems), the U.S. Department of Justice (Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs), Office of Inspector General, and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development guidelines for multinationals that the compliance function should have sufficient authority and autonomy from management and direct access to the board, in many organizations, compliance was historically part of the legal function, and general counsel/legal are protecting “their turf.” Second, unless there is a major scandal or request from a regulator to have compliance reporting directly to the board, boards often don’t prioritize structural change and leave compliance within legal. Third, boards and management often assume that there are certain efficiencies in keeping compliance under legal rather than building an independent function. Finally, a chief compliance officer reporting to the board might challenge management decisions; therefore, some boards and management might believe it is easier to “control” compliance communication and actions if it is within legal, rather than an independent voice to the board.
A changing ethics landscape
AT: How do you think the ethics landscape has changed?
PW: I believe the ethics landscape has changed in numerous ways. There has been a shift from focusing on profit and shareholders to broader stakeholders. Corporate social responsibility has moved from optional to mandatory. Public expectations have risen sharply. Institutional investors, banks, and pension funds are deciding where to invest money, and they are focusing on companies with strong ESG. Greenwashing is no longer tolerated. Diversity and inclusion, #MeToo, Black Lives Matter, and climate changehave become global movements that impact corporate
ethics. Multinational companies with global operations are impacted by different trade sanction regimes, must decide whether to withdraw from operations in Russia/Israel, and are expected to comply with numerous supply chain laws. Technological innovations such as face recognition, AI, autonomous driving, genetically modified food, and social media have created new ethical dilemmas. Fake news, misinformation, hate, hallucination, bias in decision-making, and lack of transparency in algorithms are some of the ethical challenges. Digital ethics around data privacy; increased responsibility for social media providers under legislation like the EU’s Digital Services Act; and ethical use of AI in regard to fairness, accountability, and human oversight require strong focus and governance from companies. Employees, consumers, and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) are more active than they were many years ago, so the likelihood that they will speak up as whistleblowers or take legal action against companies for unethical practices is likely to increase.
Making the case to management
AT: Let me break my following question into two parts. First, how do we get management to recognize the value of compliance programs?
PW: As with every function, compliance must “sell” itself and show the value it creates. Compliance must measure the impact/effectiveness of its compliance resources. Compliance can show its value by quantifying costs avoided (fines and legal fees, investigation expenses prevented); using key performance indicators (KPIs) that support strategic business objectives (e.g., improved employee morale, reduced sexual harassment by X%, increased ESG rating, reduced third-party risk by X%, increased assurance through data analytics); and turning compliance data into business intelligence with dashboards on incident trends, culture survey data, speak-up numbers, etc.
AT: This is a bit of a sad question, but how do we get management to turn that recognition into support? As we all know, there is often a gap between the value management sees and their willingness to invest.
PW: To get management support for compliance, we need to provide evidence (for value created), we need to tie compliance activities to business outcomes, we need to sell compliance as an essential part of enterprise risk management, and the compliance department must highlight the regulatory expectations on compliance to management. Compliance departments should create dashboards and reports that make compliance results visible and understandable for management and the board. This can be done by celebrating internal success stories where compliance department supported the business (e.g., launching a new product, commercializing a new AI application, winning a major contract, or significantly reducing compliance risks when working with third parties). This can also be done by promoting case studies or showcasing how the compliance department avoided hefty fines that competitors had to pay. Rather than saying there is an obligation to comply with laws and being perceived as a cost center and innovation blocker, compliance departments must speak the language of the business/management and use more operational KPIs to showcase their success. For instance, the compliance department should highlight how they helped increase revenues, avoid costs, finalize a successful merger and acquisition deal, get a better ESG rating, improve brand reputation, etc. The compliance department must furthermore identify champions in the leadership team who can advocate for and promote compliance in executive leadership meetings; it should also partner with allies (risk, human resources, finance, etc.) who can support them as a necessary function. Compliance is also well-advised to focus on providing business insights and intelligence (forward-looking) rather than conducting retrospective monitoring. Finally, the compliance department must communicate expectations from regulators, stakeholders, and investors (e.g., ESG frameworks) regarding compliance and governance.
What boards think about compliance
AT: What about the board? You have served as a company director and have great insights into how they think. First, what would you say is their thinking when it comes to compliance programs?
PW: Boards understand that a major compliance incident or failure can have serious reputational and financial implications; therefore, they are worried whether the company has the right culture, organizational processes, and controls that would prevent such a scenario from happening. Of course, there is also a personal interest here: with increased shareholder claims and personal liability of boards, boards want to avoid personal risks and want to make sure that they ask the right questions, exercise oversight, and that the compliance program can withstand external review. Boards often see compliance as part of the bigger enterprise risk landscape. Unfortunately, many board members do not have operational compliance experience and, hence, are often not familiar with what is needed to implement an effective compliance program. When it comes to compliance, they want assurance that it is effective; they want confidence that the program is credible, measurable, and aligned with organizational strategy — and that management is genuinely committed to it.
AT: How attuned are boards to ethical considerations, not just legal and business issues?
PW: Because of increased expectations from investors on a company’s ESG performance, there is increased focus on ethics, sustainability, and social impact. ESG, AI use, corporate culture, and risks are often on board agendas. Increased transparency reporting requirements and stakeholder activism (NGO, government, patient groups, consumers) further increase board awareness about ethical topics and make them think about a company’s mission, purpose, and relationship to various stakeholders. However, not all boards have dedicated ethics/ sustainability committees to discuss ethical business considerations. The more diverse the board is in terms of age, gender, nationality, and professional experience (certainly having board members with ethics and compliance experience would help), the more likely ethical discussions will happen. Boards with limited diversity and a focus on short-term results, on the other hand, will probably focus on financial results rather than discussing ethical dilemmas.
AT: What do you think we need to do to help them think more positively about the profession and the role?
PW: Many boards and management understand and recognize the magnitude of compliance, but at the same time do not see it as a strategic capability. The compliance department must therefore reframe compliance as a strategic enabler and not as a control function. The compliance department should consider linking compliance to company values, mission, and ESG, and focus on how good compliance creates opportunities (e.g., new product launches, access to new markets, reduced risks). The compliance department must also show its value add (i.e., the return on compliance). Only when compliance can show a measurable impact will it avoid being seen as just a cost center. This can be done through compliance KPIs that are tied to business objectives. Rather than a police/control function, the compliance department should act more as a trusted adviser, someone who helps leadership make sound and ethical decisions. Compliance officers should have a deep business understanding, strategic thinking, cooperative cross-functionality, and be change agents.
Compliance officers in the boardroom
AT: I often think that part of our problem is the lack of compliance officers on boards. Do you think there is any possibility of changing that?
PW: Historically, boards have been populated with people who have finance, law, or operations backgrounds. As ESG and corporate integrity are becoming more important — both are rooted in strong compliance frameworks — there is an increased chance for compliance officers to be part of the board. Additionally, the risks for which finance, law, or operations were voted into board roles have been expanded to AI, cybersecurity, ESG, and human rights. Chief compliance officers are excellent candidates for board positions as they are masters of these disciplines. After the Enron scandal, guidance came out that boards must have at least one person with financial expertise. Considering that many high-profile cases with ethical misconduct, fraud, or irregularities often relate to a weak compliance culture, one would hope that professional compliance associations lobby at all levels to have at least one person on the board with in-depth compliance expertise. Similarly, the compliance community and compliance associations such as SCCE should further promote compliance as a strategic discipline.
AT: What advice would you give to a compliance officer looking to become an outside director? What skills should they develop? What should they do to better position themselves?
PW: For a compliance officer to become an outside director, they need good business understanding. They need to understand strategy, industry trends, external factors impacting the company/industry, digital risks, cybercrime, market expansion strategies, and financial literacy. Compliance officers already bring integrity, ethics, and risk management to the table, but they might want to consider further developing skills in cross-functional leadership and influence, anticipating and managing crises, stakeholder management, and/or governance. Executive programs for board members or aspiring board members exist that focus exactly on these aspects. Aspiring candidates for outside director positions should consider joining a not-for-profit board, consider finding a “mentor,” and establish themselves as a strategic governance leader rather than a compliance expert.
AT: We have seen a lot of regulatory changes driven by Europe lately. Privacy, human trafficking and modern slavery, and climate rules are all examples. What is your sense of what comes next?
PW: Giving the growing importance of digital platforms and data, I would see an increased value and focus on data privacy, cybersecurity, and AI, but also increased requirements on transparency reporting, sustainability (PFAS, digital product passports, waste management), transparency in supply chain networks, increased complexity in navigating geopolitical risks, and trade sanctions and workplace-related investigations. Traditional compliance activities, such as antitrust, anti-corruption, and conflicts of interest, can, of course, not be neglected. Due to this ever-increasing list of regulatory requirements, companies must have sound and agile risk assessment methodologies, standardized data-capture nomenclatures, common software platforms where — across the world — some of the above risks can be captured and reported. As some of the risks affect numerous departments, cross-functional teams to address them must be set up. Governance methodologies around AI and third-party risk management remain vital.
Regulation and AI: What comes next
AT: All these new and potential regulations and the emergence of AI all mean we are moving into a different world. How should ethics and compliance programs evolve to be more effective in it?
PW: Ethics and compliance teams should be involved from the initial start of an AI project, including the initial design and development stages. To ensure AI is used ethically, and to follow principles of the EU AI Act, ethics impact assessments should be conducted prior to launch; companies should define an AI policy; ethical principles such as transparency, human oversight, fairness, and competition should be created; and an AI governance or AI ethics review board with members from IT, data science, legal, and compliance should exist. Ethics and compliance programs — regarding AI — should have clear roles and responsibilities across design, development, and rollout; documentation standards; and workflows (who approves what, when, where, and why based on what data). Compliance professionals should explore how AI can further facilitate and simplify their work. Therefore, it is recommended to run test cases to see how AI can help with policy development, monitoring, third-party due diligence, investigations, etc.
AT: One of the concerning elements of AI is that it has no sense of right and wrong. How can we ensure that ethical considerations are counted into the algorithm, or at least the oversight?
PW: The EU AI Act has already defined critical ethical principles. To ensure AI is used ethically, the following elements should be considered:
Companies must develop ethical values to ensure AI makes the right decisions.
These ethical values must be built into the AI model (ethical design), and regular testing is needed to ensure that the AI system is not acting unethically (e.g., bias).
Users must be able to understand which data was used, how the AI model was trained, and its intended use. The logic of the AI model/system should be explained so that unfair or unethical decisions are found.
AI algorithms should be continuously monitored for harmful effects as real-world data changes.
Human oversight should be required on high-risk AI applications (e.g., in medicine).
Clear roles and responsibilities must be defined in the company.
AT: Thanks for sharing with our readers, Patrick!
The ISO 37008 Internal investigation standard framework and what this means for financial services institutions
Introduction
The Association of Corporate Investigators (ACi) contributed, as experts, to the drafting of the International Standards Organisation’s (ISO) ‘Internal Investigations of Organizations — Guidance’ (ISO 37008). The guidance was published in July 2023. The guidance forms part of the ISO 37000 range of ISO guidance which include:
ISO 37000 ‘Governance of Organizations’;
ISO 37001 ‘Anti-Bribery Management Systems’;
ISO 37002 ‘Whistleblowing Management Systems’;
ISO 37003 ‘Fraud Control Management Systems’;
ISO 37004 ‘Governance Maturity Model’;
ISO 37005 ‘Developing Governance Indicators’;
ISO 37006 ‘Effective Organisational Governance’;
ISO 37007 — Pending;
ISO 37008 ‘Internal Investigations of Organizations’;
ISO 37009 ‘Conflict of Interest in Organizations’.
The 37000 series of ISO publications falls within the remit of ISO Technical Committee (TC) 309.1 ‘TC 309 Governance of Organizations was established in September 2016 to address “standardization in the field of governance relating to aspects of direction, control, and accountability of organizations”’.
It must be noted that the documents in the ISO 37000 series are guidance documents and not standards per se. It would be fair to say that within financial services institutions there are ‘believers’ and ‘non-believers’ in ISO standards and guidance documents, primarily due to a number of deeply entrenched methodologies led by those without a clear mindset for change. For example, many financial services institutions follow the guidance provided in ISO 37301 ‘Compliance Management Systems’ and feel that this is sufficient to provide guidance for establishing, developing, implementing, evaluating, maintaining and improving an effective and responsive compliance management system within organisations. Compliance (in the context of ISO 37301) is not an ‘investigation’, however, with good governance and compliance seeking to give comfort to what ‘should be’, as opposed to having to investigate an issue or concern as a result of poor governance or control weaknesses. Following the guidance in the 37000 series of guidance documents supports the overall objective of maintaining a robust overall compliance programme, and ISO 37008 enhances the investigative element.
As financial services institutions fall with the regulated sector, they should find that following ISO 37000 series guidance adds to the armoury of (and approach to) the three lines of defence model as a further tool to strengthen the organisations overall risk, control and governance environments.
What Is An Internal Investigation?
Investigations are a reality for financial services institutions. Any organisation — small, medium or large — will find itself having to conduct internal investigations into a wide range of issues or, indeed, may need the services of external providers to do this for it. The ISO guidance states an investigation is an integral part of organisational management — a professional fact-finding process, initiated by (or for) an organisation, to establish facts in relation to alleged or suspected wrongdoing, misconduct or non-compliance (such as bribery and corruption, fraud, bullying and harassment, violence, discrimination or indeed other breaches of an organisational code of conduct). In the financial services sector, the word ‘investigation’ can be found in many contexts. For example, in banks, payment operations can investigate error payments or transaction monitoring teams can investigate transaction monitoring alerts. Nevertheless, the word investigation is more commonly associated with allegations of wrongdoing, misconduct or non-compliance, all of which sit clearly within a background of governance or business integrity.
The functions and tasks financial services institutions apply to the word ‘investigation’ is part of the reason clarity is needed in the organisation’s governance documents.
What Does Good Investigative Governance Look Like?
ISO 37008 speaks to the need for organisations to have a clearly defined and written investigations policy or procedure. In reality, financial services institutions as a regulated sector will need both.
If the ISO standard is considered in the context of what financial services institutions should think about when considering good investigative governance, the following key questions arise:
If the financial services institution has an investigative function, where does the function sit in the organisational structure?
If the financial services institution is a small or medium-sized business and contracts out investigations to external providers, how is the management of investigations covered in the governance model?
As almost all financial services institutions operate the three lines of defence model (a model for managing risk and controls in organisations), which line of defence in the organisation is best suited to house the investigative function?
Who is the accountable executive at executive committee level responsible for the investigation function?
How are significant investigations reported to the board?
As the financial services institution is in the regulated sector, are there regulatory rules or guidance that must be followed in the jurisdictions in which it operates?
Is the reporting line for the head of the investigations function clear, and does it involve matrix reporting lines?
Is the mandate for the investigative function clear and documented in policy?
Which oversight committee(s) have responsibility for investigations in their terms of reference?
What investigations management information (MI) do they require, and do they have rights of challenge?
Is the remit of the investigations function clearly defined in terms of matters it is charged to investigate under its responsibility?
If a case triage process exists to refer cases to other functions or externally, is this clearly documented in a policy, procedure or process document?
Do functions mandated to undertake different types of investigations have suitably qualified and skilled staff to undertake investigations?
These are all fundamental, and the list is not exhaustive. It is, however, thought-provoking when addressing investigation governance needs.
Financial services institutions commonly have their investigative function seated firmly within an audit or legal reporting line. However, this does not necessarily suggest that the reporting line means that there is no presence at board level, and this is often managed through an accountable executive who is responsible for the function, albeit the head of investigations has a line of sight to the board and indeed any supervisory board or non-executive directors. This provides the necessary comfort and assurance, and some organisations have created a business integrity function which embraces both the investigative and whistleblowing management functions.
The ACi advise the following investigations governance documents for financial services institutions:
charter or similar document, with the investigations mandate and details of who is responsible for investigations.
investigations policy which covers the remit, case triage and allocation process, together with who holds the responsibility for investigating cases of varying types;
investigations procedures manual which outlines the procedures investigators must follow when conducting investigations;
oversight committee(s) terms of reference and reporting requirements (management information) for investigations;
investigation response plan for significant cases meeting materiality thresholds determined by the financial services institutions in accordance with its risk appetite;
investigation function process documents for internal processes and templates for investigation plans, for recording the scope, investigative actions, timelines and final reports.
It is important financial services institutions draft and apply investigation governance documents that are aligned to the existing organisational governance models. The documents are not intended to replace or sit outside an existing framework but should complement such a framework by being relevant to the investigation space. Regulators look for a clear delineation of roles and responsibilities for financial service institutions operating a three lines of defence model.
Adopting And Applying ‘Principles’
Many financial services institutions have openly stated the values and behaviours which they apply when conducting business and codes of conduct applicable to their employees (including third parties and contractors). Those responsible for conducting investigations — especially into members of staff — are expected to apply the highest levels of ethics and integrity.
ISO 37008, Section 4 sets out five key principles which should be applied to all investigations regardless of type:
independent;
confidential;
competent and professional;
objective and impartial; and
legal and lawful.
In accessing what the guidance means for financial services institutions, the adoption of these investigation principles would have no downside.
The Investigation Process
ISO 37008 sets out a process which can be applied to investigations. It is neatly summarised in Figure 1.
Section 8 of the ISO 37008 guidance presents a helpful investigation process many financial services institutions with dedicated investigation teams will be familiar with. Assessing what it means is a more focused and robust procedure and process for the conduct of investigations.
What Support Is Offered For Internal Investigations?
ISO 37008 addresses the support organisations are expected to provide and include but are not limited to personnel, financial, technical and organisational infrastructure. These resources can be provided internally or externally, with many institutions focused on cost. The use of technology during investigations, especially in the areas of data mining, searching and e-discovery, may well result in significant cost savings in the longer term and, together with the increasing use of artificial intelligence (AI) in the investigations space, adds value in terms of search speeds, efficiency and accuracy. Depending on the size of the financial institution and case volumes, investing in investigations technology remains a judgment call in terms of the return on that investment in a marketplace that is increasingly growing in terms of new products.
Financial services institutions also need to consider the benefits of contracting out investigations to external providers, such as law firms and consultancies. Contracting out the forensic elements of any case to specialist forensic companies with specialist tools may well prove highly productive in the long run, as such technology may not be available in house. Indeed, in certain circumstances financial services institutions may decide to contract out the entire investigation to an external law firm. This is a consideration when legal privilege needs to be applied over investigation-related legal advice and when litigation is contemplated. A further consideration is a case for which self-reporting to the authorities is advised and working with regulators and investigative authorities in (for example in bribery and corruption cases).
Where Does ‘Protection, Safeguarding And Anti-Retaliation’ Fit In For Those Impacted By Investigations?
ISO 37008 addresses the protection, safeguarding and well-being of all persons involved in the investigation process, in particular, whistleblowers, who raise concerns and in many jurisdictions are afforded protection under the law. Apart from any legal or regulatory obligations to protect whistleblowers, financial services institutions should ensure they promote a ‘speak-up’ culture and a tone from the top which encourages staff to raise concerns directly with their line manager or via the whistleblowing channels provided by the organisation (internally and/or externally). This should include (unless prohibited by law) a channel for anonymous whistleblowing.
Financial services institutions should ensure that those charged with undertaking investigations are professionally managed as investigations can be a demanding and challenging area in which to work. This is clearly necessary where cases involve serious wrongdoing, which can include criminal behaviour, and often where members of staff, particularly those in senior roles, are involved. Investigators should be free from bias or influence, especially in cases that have a significant impact on the organisation’s revenue and profitability. They should investigate without fear or favour and be confident in the organisation’s support from the C-suite in the event of undue pressure from business management.
Those who manage investigations should be appropriately trained and versed in identifying signs of stress in those charged with conducting investigations and in managing staff in high pressure and time-sensitive roles. The mental health and well-being of all colleagues is a priority and particularly so when a high-profile investigation is taking place within a financial services institution.
What Does Iso 37008 Consider Regarding ‘Control Improvements’ (Or Thematic/Lessons Learned) And Stakeholder Engagement?
ISO 37008 recognises the importance of lessons learned from investigations and the importance of improving the control environment. Financial services institutions can benefit greatly from control weaknesses identified during the course of investigations and associated remedial recommendations and actions.
It is important that any control gaps identified during the course of an investigation are closed immediately and legal, risk and compliance experts do not wait for the conclusion of the investigation to take action. This also applies when remediation is identified and required. In the area of financial crime compliance, this has potential regulatory impacts; hence the key message is ‘don’t wait, and act promptly’.
The guidance recognises the need for effective stakeholder engagement within organisations. Financial services institutions have many moving parts, with many teams often working in silos. An effective investigation requires honest communication and engaging with many stakeholders at all levels with the financial institution. For significant investigations, the investigation response plan should provide a template for success.
Where Does The Investigative Function Best Sit In An Organisation?
As the result of the ACi participation in the drafting of ISO 37008, and following its publication, some financial services institutions sought a view from the ACi on a range of investigative issues. Indeed, the two most frequently asked questions were whether the investigative function should be centralised (or not) and where is an internal investigative function best ‘housed’ (in terms of reporting line).
The centralisation of an internal investigative often considers the question of what type of investigation is being conducted. For example, financial crime requires a different set of investigative disciplines from those required for senior leadership misconduct, although both are ‘investigations’ per se. The range of skills may lead more naturally towards compliance in the case of financial crime and potentially human resources (HR) for misconduct matters. Indeed, matters relating to sanctions, anti-money laundering (AML) or bribery and corruption can be within the remit of specialists within financial crime compliance.
External fraud investigations are often managed internally through operational risk teams, with internal fraud and serious employee wrongdoing frequently housed within specialised and dedicated investigation teams or within internal audit. Breaches of organisational codes of conduct and expected employee values and behaviours generally sit within HR.
Simply put, investigations are often not a ‘one-size-fits-all’.
The ACi promotes the benefits of a centralised team that is able to provide investigative support to specialists for all investigations. The primary benefit of this is to ensure good investigative efficacy and solid best practice and, fundamentally, to develop knowledge and thought leadership from thematic lessons learned and the drive for consistency.
The exact remit of the cases a centralised team should investigate is a matter for each organisation. However the investigations policy should clearly state ‘who does what’. The ACi’s view is that centralisation allows for better concentration of investigative expertise and management, cross-leveraging of investigative resources and standard investigation procedures with dedicated training and a robust and detailed quality assurance programme.
Turning to the question of ‘where’ a function should sit — or reporting lines — in an organisation, the ACi see compliance as the right functional area for investigations. Many organisations refer to this as ethics and compliance or business integrity, but essentially it has a direct line of sight to the very top of an organisation. Fundamentally, the working relationship with legal and risk should be extremely strong. Compliance may well be a second line of defence; however, compliance officers must also consider the risk of individual criminal liability. It is indeed why regulators favour ‘compliance’ as their accountability goes far beyond ‘in-house’ or regulatory sanctions and may well enter the criminal sphere.
Iso 37008: A Detailed Case Study
Background and context
An eloquent example of success following the implementation of ISO 37008 is to look at a recent review of ISO 37008 within a large and highly successful multinational financial services organisation, beset by a number of investigative challenges following a number of concerns and allegations which were raised against the organisation and its senior leadership team.
Over a five-year period, the organisation faced numerous procedural and internal policy challenges surrounding its internal investigations process. This followed a regulatory investigation which, while finding the concerns unsubstantiated, commented on the lack of updated relevant processes and policies, and that necessitated a thorough review and overhaul.
Predominantly operating in the EU and before adopting the ISO standard, the organisation confirmed that it had experienced a number of inconsistencies within its processes, leading to a perceived lack of transparency and prolonged case life cycles; mainly as a result of failing to have a clearly defined decision and action logging process. The organisational leadership team welcomed a root and branch review in order to support deeper learning and any corrective actions necessary.
After implementing ISO 37008, a notable transformation occurred within the investigation process. Standardised, and fundamentally ‘business agreed’ procedures incorporated the clear guiding investigative principles, which afforded greater consistency and efficiency within internal investigations. All of these were reinforced through ACi learning and thought leadership. Training became a clear bedrock for change and the introduction of new and updated methodologies improved the quality of triage, assessment and fieldwork enquiries. Additionally, the implementation of technological enhancements streamlined eDiscovery and data collection/analysis processes, which had been clearly lacking focus within internal investigations, where the reliance had been on third parties providing such services who lacked the detailed and deeper understanding of concerns within supporting business functions.
Crucial to the success of onboarding the ISO 37088 standard was the training and development of competent investigators which not only encompassed the core investigative team, but also drew in a mix of colleagues from HR, legal, compliance and business integrity. All may have played a part in previous investigations, whether directly or by being co-opted, and were included as a result of their individual roles, skill sets and expertise. The organisation invested in numerous investigative related training programmes, from the effective triage and assessment of allegations, the planning and development, how to conduct trauma-informed interviews with reporters, witnesses and subjects, key report writing skills and the management of key internal and external stakeholders. Governing principles were fundamental to the company’s success, with each practically applied in all cases and matters under investigation.
Overall, key investigative skills were strengthened and enhanced with a culture of continuous professional learning and development embedded and knowledge and thought leadership crucial to the success of thematic learning shared. The standard reviewed all elements of procedural change, and the results were impressive. Improved investigative efficiencies were found in many areas, including the development and use of e-discovery technology (in house) and specialised investigative tools for use during interviews (contemporaneous notes taken from digitally recorded interviews). Case management systems and reporting tools were improved, together with disclosure protocols for used and unused materials driven by further streamlined collection, analysis and documentation of evidence/data.
Deep thematic learning followed, with the ability to track cases, concerns and allegations more accurately, share information more securely and generate more concise investigation reports, which were still highly detailed in many cases, all leading to more informed and focused decision making.
Nevertheless, there were challenges faced. The most frequently observed was a resistance to change from experienced investigators, who ‘had always done things their way’ and were reluctant to consider new ways of working with a view to increasing efficiency. Overcoming this took time and effort, and there was a real need to be open and honest with each other. To complement the process, awareness programmes, enhanced effective communication and the longer-term benefits of change were slowly and deliberately introduced.
Technology also presented its own problems to the organisation. Adapting to (and accepting) innovative technology met with resistance in the learning curve. This necessitated detailed and informative training sessions, a 24-7-365 approach to technical support for investigators and, above all, a continuous drive by senior leaders to push for change.
Having been through the process of implementing the standard, the procedural and policy enhancements, training, technical integration and overcoming various challenges have ensured that the organisation has strengthened its ability to manage investigative risk, has become even more regulatory compliant and, above all, is continuously improving within the entire case life cycle. The ISO 37008 framework has enhanced and elevated trust in the internal investigative process, supported the organisational governance and compliance aims and overall has meant that concerns and allegations are dealt with quickly, robustly and effectively, which has instilled a far deeper culture of trust and openness in the organisation.
Why was ISO 37008 chosen as a framework?
Simply put, following the news in July 2023 that ISO 37008 had followed a two-year process involving experts from different countries, the standard for the internal investigations of organisations was seen to be the most effective driver for change.
As a global standard, ISO 37008 reflects international best practices for internal investigations conducted in corporates and multinationals across the world, and this includes financial services institutions. By design, it appeals. The standard can be used and adopted by any organisation, irrespective of size, and in any country as the standard is malleable to size, industry/segment, structure, governing body, regulatory focus and type of concern or allegation. Knowing that internal investigations should be conducted independently and in an objective and impartial manner, the organisation was aware that, at its core, it already had competent and professional investigators who managed and applied an attention to detail that would be seen as commensurate with applicable law(s) while maintaining confidentiality. But this was not enough.
The standard was noted for being able to facilitate interaction with internal and external stakeholders, with clearly defined procedural recommendations, including the main aspects of cooperation with regulators and other (enforcement) authorities. Incorporating matters that might require regulatory disclosure into a more robust framework was seen as crucial to new ways of working and required the support and leadership of the organisation to drive the standard forwards, together with the application of revised policies, processes and procedures.
A closer examination
The organisation closely compared existing procedures with the benefits achievable with ISO 37008 before embarking on change. This is noteworthy in terms of understanding what this means for the wider financial services community irrespective of organisational size and whether scalable change is possible. Identifying the occasions when internal investigations are required and change would benefit the process necessitated a change of approach for matters arising through internal ethics, compliance, governance or whistleblowing activity and requiring immediate response. The initial signs were promising, and the overall result was outstanding.
Regulatory scrutiny on certain matters — both financial crime and associated senior misconduct — focused the attention and conversations, with substantial improvement seen in the overall reduction of risk, whether financial or reputational. Thematic learning and thought leadership lessons shared learning with those making — and taking — corrective action, in order to ensure the lessons learned had practically applied mitigations and solutions to support the organisation.
The ISO standard provides the framework and the essential aspects of any investigation. If followed, it should satisfy all organisational requirements. While drafted generically, it was tailored to the organisation and its specific needs with a simple, ready-made and deployable process without significant cost. This approach is often lacking in many organisations, and the ISO standard applied in this instance has now highlighted the simplicity of application for many others as a highly effective model.
As the standard provides guidance on the life cycle of an internal investigation (the design and implementation of relevant investigative policies and procedures, investigation frameworks, recommended reporting practices following completion and the oversight and ownership of remedial measures) the organisation embarked on a ‘total framework review’ encompassing all elements of the standard. Specific focus was given to the principles adhering to:
independence;
confidentiality;
competence;
professionalism;
objectivity;
impartiality; and
legality.
These seem to be the most crucial for the organisation.
While the application of these principles was, in the main, relatively organised, it was seen as disparate with competing influences at many stages of the internal investigation life cycle. While most stood the test of acceptability, it was definitely at ‘bronze standard’ level as opposed to ‘gold’ or ‘platinum’. Widespread improvement was achievable in all life-cycle pillars, including triage, assessment, fieldwork, interviewing and reporting. Key to the success of implementation was to follow the guidance and standards taken from the ‘Uniform Principles of Investigations and Good Practice Guidance’ issued by the ACi.
The standard’s emphasis on senior management support during internal investigations provided a splendid bedrock on which the investigative function could rely, with a keen desire to learn far more from examples of potential misconduct, regulatory compliance and other concerns and allegations. This was crucial to the embedding of not only new ways of working but also a cultural change within the organisation.
Among the areas identified requiring change were:
Pre-investigation stage: A lack of understanding at the preparatory stage led to confusion as to what exactly would be investigated, and what policy, process or law this was in breach of. The triaging and assessment of concerns required revision. The concerns were previously made to ‘fit’ case management system identification (eg ‘pigeon-holing’ matters) as opposed to satisfying clearly identifiable concern data, and investigation teams were not mobilised to consider skills and expertise together with learning. An attitude of ‘I’ve done this before, so I’m best suited to do it again’ led to a silo mentality. Case and thematic learnings were not shared, and therefore, a way to mobilise the most effective investigation team was necessary.
Fieldwork (and the conduct of the investigation): Methodology flaws were identified in the stages of preservation of evidence, protection afforded to those reporting (including witnesses) and the prevention of interference with the investigation process. Also required was an appropriate document management approach, together with the maintenance of a ‘decision and action log’ which clearly stated actions taken and any deviation from process. While the interview process was relatively sound, the introduction of a methodology to address audio and video recording of interviews was required. Such recordings often provide the most crucial evidential value and are an essential pillar of any successful investigation. Document management and e-discovery processes were acceptable, largely centred around the identification and preservation of essential documents and evidence, although these were mostly handled by third party providers. The organisation was keen to bring this activity in-house. All contributed to a well-considered and documented final investigation report, with report writing skills requiring training and education for all authors.
Post-investigation stage: It was the change to reporting at the final investigative stages that proved to be the most crucial element for post-investigative efforts. Improved reporting led to clear, accurate and easily applicable remedial measures to be recommended. These ultimately led to an improved overhaul and adjustment to the organisation’s existing compliance structure. Crucial decisions by the organisation’s senior management were better understood, including whether to self-report breaches to the relevant authorities, something which had previously faltered. The interaction with external stakeholders and remedial measures required to address the situation were seen as fundamental to organisational investigative improvement and strengthened resilience against potential financial and reputational risks.
The Overall Benefits
Adopting ISO 37008 realises substantial benefits to any internal investigative function, whether independently operated or forming part of an ethics, compliance, governance or business integrity function. The standard provides a highly robust and solid procedural framework, ensuring best practice, consistency and quality assurance throughout all investigative phases.
In this instance, by following the ACi guiding principles and those adopted within ISO 37008 the organisation significantly enhanced all areas of investigative effectiveness from the receipt of concerns and allegations to triaging, assessment and initial identification to investigation, resolution and follow-up. Furthermore, the standard acts as a primary guardian and internal verifier of any ethics and integrity programme, establishing clear guidelines for investigative conduct, reinforcing internal and external trust with key stakeholders and strengthening the organisation’s position against potential regulatory, legal and reputational challenge.
The ACi Gap Analysis
As the implementation process of the standard is a methodical and structured pathway towards investigative excellence, it begins with a thorough assessment and gap analysis of existing related processes, identifies areas for improvement and aligns them with the ISO standard requirements. A clear action plan is developed to ensure that roles, responsibilities and investigative deadlines are agreed, with the emphasis on developed learning and thought leadership through relevant training to ensure those investigating understand and adhere to the standard. Something that is important here is the correct documenting of policy and procedures, with a robust case/investigative management system being essential to ensure operational investigative integrity. It is driven by what currently exists; it is not a rewrite of existing policy and process but a simple audit of processes and gaps which leads to the management of effective investigative efficacy and the benefits of external certification, ensuring that the organisation complies with the rigorous standards of ISO 37008. The standard not only establishes the correct guidelines for effective management of internal investigations but also plays a crucial role in managing risk, and the requirements of regulatory compliance.
Organisations that consider a gap analysis and adopt ISO 37008 are able to demonstrate their enhanced ability to identify, assess and mitigate internal investigative risks, thereby creating an environment where an agile and efficient response to potential threats is always in place, from the receipt of concerns through the case life cycle to reporting.
Regulatory compliance is satisfied by ensuring that ethical, compliant and legal guidelines for internal investigations are maintained, particularly where the matter is the subject of legal privilege. This helps to avoid potential sanctions and penalties and also thoroughly reinforces the integrity of investigative and business practice.